By Jeff Popple
When a new non-stop flight appears in a market that previously only had connecting service, where does the traffic come from?
We all know the “Southwest effect”: add a low-fare non-stop and the market grows. My working theory was that a new non-stop’s traffic comes from two places: stimulation (new travelers) and siphoning (connecting passengers switching to the non-stop). I wanted to investigate that theory.
The analysis
I used US DB1B data to compare Q2 2023 with Q2 2025. I looked at city pairs with no non-stop traffic in 2023 that had a single carrier operating a non-stop in 2025. I excluded markets with fewer than 20 sample passengers, which left roughly 200 markets.
What the data showed
- Total market traffic roughly tripled. It went from about 4,400 to 13,400 passengers per day, up about 200%.
- The non-stop carried 67% of the 2025 market and accounted for essentially all of the net growth.
- Connecting traffic barely moved. It was about 4,430 passengers per day in 2023 and about 4,406 in 2025.
- Fares fell sharply. The blended fare across all passengers dropped about 46%, from $295 to $158 one-way equivalent. The average 2025 non-stop fare was about $99, roughly two-thirds below the 2023 connecting fare.
The fare drop explains a lot of the stimulation. What surprised me is that the connecting passengers didn’t go anywhere. I expected meaningful siphoning, but in aggregate the non-stop’s traffic was almost entirely incremental. (Flat connecting traffic doesn’t prove nobody switched. Some switching could be offset by new connecting demand. But it does suggest siphoning is a much smaller part of the story than I assumed.)
Not all non-stops are equal
The type of carrier matters enormously. Breeze, Allegiant, and Avelo operated about 170 of these new non-stops and carried roughly 78% of the 2025 traffic.
The pattern is clear. Where the new non-stop came in at a fraction of the old connecting fare, the market exploded. Where the fare barely changed, growth was modest.
The forecasting problem
If a market can triple or grow twelve-fold depending on who enters and at what price, how does an airline forecast a new non-stop?
Fare is the obvious starting point: how much does a market grow for every X% the fare drops? But even with lower fares, the passengers have to come from somewhere. The data suggests the answer isn’t diverted connecting passengers. It’s people who weren’t flying this O&D before, or weren’t flying at all.
That makes the other drivers of stimulation worth modeling explicitly. A few I’d start with:
- The type of carrier adding the non-stop and its price positioning
- City demographics
- Catchment area, and what other airports compete for it
- Drivability of the O&D, since a short drive caps how much a non-stop can stimulate
What am I missing?
What other factors do you use to forecast market stimulation when evaluating a new non-stop? I’d love to hear how others approach it.
Keep in mind my data used DB1B data, which is only a 10% sample. So, numbers are approximate. Also, by excluding markets with a sample less than 20, it leans toward non-stops that succeeded. It doesn’t capture routes that launched and failed or were never launched. So, the growth multiples here are likely higher than what a typical new non-stop would see. A forecast should account for that.
About the Author:
Jeff Popple is Director of Customer Success at Zulu Airline Systems.